I have two trees and two cats. The fake one is in the kitchen where they are most of the time and I have covered it in wooden decorations which shouldn't break. I am hoping this is the one they favour. I also only gradually decked - trees up first day, tinsel and lights the second, baubles the third. They are rescues so new to me this year. So far, nothing broken.... good luck! X edited in line with your edit - I tell them off when scratching and have a great tool for mending the fabric sofa. I have lots of coir doormats for them to scratch through the house and a few specific cat ones x